Not unlike many of my neighbors and peers, I've been paying between a quarter and a dollar extra per half-gallon to feed my child organic cow's milk since he began drinking it.
My reasons for this are a little foggy (not unlike my reasons for many of my parenting choices.) I don't like the idea of extra hormones being pumped into my baby's body. I do like the idea of the cows being treated well. Part of me thinks it tastes better. I know organic farming is better for the environment than non-organic, though many argue against the farming of cows at all, but that's another blog. Now that I'm pregnant, I laugh in the general direction of anyone who suggests that I shouldn't drink cow's milk. I dream about the stuff. Ummm... oh, and I buy it because for some reason it makes me feel good.
I was pretty happy going along buying the least expensive carton I could find... scouring the stores, really, for organic milk bargains. I was pretty pleased with the invention of "ultra-pasturization," so I could buy several half-gallons at a time and it wouldn't go bad.
Then I spoke to one of my friends who is just slightly on the more aware side of her grocery consumption. I told her about the bargains to be had at Costco -- three organic half-gallons for eight bucks! Unheard of! In my neighborhood, one half-gallon can go for $4.60. She replied, "I haven't read up on the Costco milk, so I haven't bought it." Normally I would think, "Ok, so she has to read about food before she buys it? That's a little too cautious for the likes of lazy old me." But this conversation came on the heels of another conversation I had with my co-workers who think I'm silly for shelling out any extra dough for organic milk. Their kids turned out just fine on regular milk. How do I even know if it is really organic... organic... organic? That last phrase repeated in my mind the way Marsha Brady's cry "Oh my nose!" repeated in that one Brady Bunch episode lodged deep in the psyche of anyone my age who was allowed to watch tv as a child.
How do I even know if it is really organic... organic... organic?
When my friend said that it came back with that same shrill Marsha Brady cry.
So I googled "organic milk Costco."
Oh boy. Football to the nose right before the big date time.
It turns out that pretty much all of those cheap brands are pretty much big fat liars. They have an organic stamp from the FDA, but they violate the codes without blinking an eye. They have 4000 cow farms! Their idea of "pasture time" is less than a walk in the prison yard. Yes, they feed the cows organic grain. But they get the calves from non-organic farms that do really gross things to their feed. Yes, they don't have the hormone problems of non-organic cows. But they are gross. F'ing heifers. (Sorry.)
One of my other friends said that she mostly cares about the fact that she's not feeding her son the hormones. The other stuff doesn't bother her. That's ok. It bothers me. It bothers me that they are taking foggy-headed parents like myself's best intentions and using them for profit without honestly delivering the goods they promise.
I don't know. Read what the Cornucopia Institute, who did the study, has to say and tell me what you think.
I think I'm willing to pay the extra quarter for happy cows and honest farmers.